FitRestFuelSearch articles
REST / BUYING GUIDE

Plank Firm vs. Plank Firm Luxe: Foam or coils for an extra-firm bed?

Both flip between firm and extra firm. Choose the support system you want, then check the exact size, cover and foundation.

Sources last checked November 2, 2026.

YOUR BUYING SHORTLIST

Check the exact configuration

Compare the details ↓

These seller links are not currently affiliate links. How our links work. Prices, stock, and terms can change.

Plank Firm

Choose it for: A deliberate firm, coil-free preference; current memory-foam identity remains unconfirmed.

Check first: Check the exact size, current cover option, foundation and delivered total. Extra firm is not a comfort guarantee.

Check price & availabilityOpens plankmattress.com · seller photos & options

Plank Firm Luxe

Choose it for: A deliberate firm or extra-firm coil preference.

Check first: Check the exact size, current cover option, foundation and delivered total. Extra firm is not a comfort guarantee.

Check price & availabilityOpens plankmattress.com · seller photos & options

Based on the evidence in this guide. Check our sources before deciding.

Jump to a section

Buy the support system you want, not the word “Luxe”

Both of these Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are designed for people who like an unusually firm sleeping surface. Both are flippable: one side is firm and the other is extra firm. You don't have to pay for the Luxe to get that choice.

The difference is underneath you. Plank Firm uses foam without support coils. Plank Firm Luxe puts an individually encased coil system between foam layers. That changes the construction, the feel you might expect, the thickness and the price.

Our starting recommendation is the original Plank Firm for someone who explicitly requested no springs. The Luxe is an alternative when a firmer hybrid is the goal. Buying a hybrid just because it has a more expensive name is no reason to spend extra.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

Two surfaces, different support cores

On a small screen, swipe the table sideways.

ChoiceMain reasonImportant drawback
Plank FirmFirm or extra firm without coilsCurrent memory-foam classification unresolved
Plank Firm LuxeFirm or extra firm with coilsCosts more; exact height needs confirmation

Comparison sources: 1, 2, 3

All foam is not automatically verified memory foam

Here's a detail worth checking if you want memory foam specifically. Brooklyn Bedding's current listing calls the material Supreme Response Comfort Foam, while an older Q&A uses the term fast-response memory foam. We couldn't confirm whether the older description still applies. We know Plank Firm has no coils, but that alone doesn't tell us exactly what kind of foam is in today's model. Ask Brooklyn Bedding before buying if the material matters to you.

On a small screen, swipe the table sideways.

QuestionPlank FirmPlank Firm Luxe
Support core6-inch high-density foam6-inch individually encased coils
Sleeping surfacesFirm and Extra FirmFirm and Extra Firm
Coil-free?YesNo
Verified memory-foam-only match?Not established for current layersNo; contains coils

The original Plank Firm has a dense foam support core. The Luxe has a 6-inch coil core plus surrounding foam components. Brooklyn Bedding positions the Luxe as more responsive and pressure-relieving than the all-foam version. Those are manufacturer descriptions, not results from FitRestFuel testing.

There's also a height discrepancy in Brooklyn Bedding's own information. Its FAQs say 10 inches for Plank Firm and 13 inches for Luxe, while its comparison lists roughly 11 and 13.25 inches. If you're buying fitted sheets or have a tight frame, ask for the current height of your exact model. We can't confidently recommend a sheet depth for Luxe until that is settled.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

How firm is “extra firm” here?

Firm and extra firm are manufacturer descriptions, not standardized measurements. Both mattresses offer two surfaces, but neither offers a soft side. Flipping the same mattress changes the sleeping surface without buying a second mattress.

A firm mattress can feel good to someone who dislikes sinking into thick comfort layers. That same feature can be uncomfortable for a side sleeper who needs more give around the shoulder and hip. A longer trial doesn't make the wrong feel right, so compare your actual preference first.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

Price matters differently at different sizes

These manufacturer standard-cover reference prices were checked November 2, 2026, before the advertised VETERANS30 discount, tax and optional cover. They are reference prices, not evidence that customers routinely paid them.

On a small screen, swipe the table sideways.

SizePlank Firm referenceLuxe referenceDifference
Twin$999.00$1,132.00$133.00
Twin XL$1,065.00$1,199.00$134.00
Full$1,265.00$1,398.00$133.00
Queen$1,465.00$1,599.00$134.00
King$1,765.00$1,932.00$167.00
California King$1,765.00$1,932.00$167.00

The Queen reference-price difference is $134; King and California King differ by $167. Compare the same size and cover in the cart, not the percentage-off banner. The selected standard-cover Luxe pages showed $839.30 for Twin XL and $1,352.40 for California King with VETERANS30. No dated end to that promotion was verified.

The Luxe premium buys the coil design and additional construction, not a third firmness option. If your only requirement is extra firm, the original already offers that side.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

The foundation and return details aren't optional

Brooklyn Bedding specifies solid, minimally flexing support or slats with gaps no greater than 5 inches. Its support guidance also permits appropriate adjustable bases. Check your exact frame, center support and its capacity for mattress plus sleepers. The published combined sleeper limit is 950 lb, not 950 lb per person; the manufacturer suggests people over 300 lb individually investigate its heavier-sleeper options. A load rating does not establish comfort.

The manufacturer advertises a 365-night trial from delivery, with at least 30 nights before a comfort return. The published policy limits use of the trial and excludes clearance items. A product-page return notice lists a $99 pickup fee, although the main return policy uses “risk-free” wording. Ask which charges and eligibility terms apply to your order before relying on a free return. Free standard shipping applies to the contiguous United States; setup, base and optional upgrades are separate.

The cooling-cover upgrade isn't free. Compare the standard mattress first. A cool-to-the-touch fabric can change the initial feel at the surface, but a marketing claim does not tell us how hot you personally will sleep.

Sources: 1, 2, 4, 5, 6

When neither Plank is the right search

Neither: You generally prefer soft to medium, need a verified all-latex mattress, or haven't checked whether an extra-firm surface is tolerable for your usual sleep position. A different product is a better search than treating either Plank as an automatic upgrade.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

Check your support before building a shopping plan

If your current bed still works and you already like its feel, buying nothing is reasonable. For a replacement, the Sleep Product Finder can compare verified size, firmness, construction and budget matches. It cannot guarantee that extra firm will feel comfortable.

Compare mattresses in the Sleep Product Finder. The category is editable; choose your own size, feel and budget.

Seller links

Return to the product details and seller links above ↑

Sources & research notes

Sources checked November 2, 2026 (Eastern Time). This is a manufacturer-sourced, research-based comparison. FitRestFuel has not conducted hands-on testing of these mattresses.

  1. Plank Firm: current construction, exact variants and prices (opens in new tab)
  2. Plank Firm Luxe: current configurations and prices (opens in new tab)
  3. Manufacturer model comparison and approximate heights (opens in new tab)
  4. Manufacturer foundation and adjustable-base requirements (opens in new tab)
  5. Plank return policy (opens in new tab)
  6. Plank returns and exchanges guidance (opens in new tab)
Back to top ↑