FitRestFuelSearch articles
REST / BUYING GUIDE

Amerisleep AS2 vs. AS3 vs. AS5: how much softness do you actually want?

Compare the AS2 medium-firm, AS3 medium and AS5 soft all-foam mattresses by build, price, size and bed frame requirements. Don't confuse them with the hybrid versions.

Sources last checked November 2, 2026.

YOUR BUYING SHORTLIST

Check the exact configuration

Compare the details ↓

These seller links are not currently affiliate links. How our links work. Prices, stock, and terms can change.

Amerisleep AS2 All Foam

Choose it for: A deliberate medium-firm preference.

Check first: Select All Foam and the exact size. A hybrid is not a coil-free substitute; confirm support, current promotion and delivered total.

Check price & availabilityOpens amerisleep.com · seller photos & options

Amerisleep AS3 All Foam

Choose it for: A medium feel without paying for extra softness.

Check first: Select All Foam and the exact size. A hybrid is not a coil-free substitute; confirm support, current promotion and delivered total.

Check price & availabilityOpens amerisleep.com · seller photos & options

Amerisleep AS5 All Foam

Choose it for: A deliberate soft feel, accepting a taller 14-inch profile.

Check first: Select All Foam and the exact size. A hybrid is not a coil-free substitute; confirm support, current promotion and delivered total.

Check price & availabilityOpens amerisleep.com · seller photos & options

Based on the evidence in this guide. Check our sources before deciding.

Jump to a section

Pick a firmness, then select the correct construction

If you're shopping for a memory foam mattress without springs, the model name isn't the whole decision. Amerisleep sells all-foam and hybrid versions of its lineup. Make sure the cart says All Foam before you compare a model with a “memory foam, no springs” requirement.

Within the all-foam versions, the choice is remarkably direct:

Those ratings are Amerisleep's own scale. We haven't slept on these mattresses or measured how they behave under different body weights. “Medium” on this line isn't guaranteed to feel identical to another company's medium.

The AS3 is our default starting point if you have no strong reason to go softer or firmer. That isn't a claim it will suit every sleep position. It simply avoids paying for the AS5's additional softness when you don't want it.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

Compare the exact configurations

On a small screen, swipe the table sideways.

ModelManufacturer's firmnessHeightMost sensible starting buyer
AS2 All FoamMedium Firm, 6/1012 inYou prefer noticeable resistance without going to an extra-firm bed
AS3 All FoamMedium, 5/1012 inYou want the middle of this range without a very soft surface
AS5 All FoamSoft, 3/1014 inYou intentionally want plush cushioning, especially around shoulders and hips

Manufacturer descriptions checked November 2, 2026, not hands-on comfort testing.

Comparison sources: 1, 2, 3

When AS5 is worth considering

Amerisleep describes the AS5 as its softest mattress. In its all-foam configuration, it uses Bio-Pur memory foam along with an Active Flex layer to add cushioning while remaining responsive. That extra layer is one reason the mattress is 14 inches tall instead of 12.

Choose this direction if you predominantly sleep on your side, have repeatedly found medium mattresses too firm and know you want more surface give. The important words are “know you want.” A softer mattress cannot repair a bed frame that doesn't support the mattress, and more softness isn't a universal remedy for aches.

The drawback is straightforward. Someone who likes a steady, flatter feel may dislike AS5's plushness. It also requires deeper fitted sheets and is physically bulkier than the AS2 and AS3. If you add a topper or mattress pad, measure the mattress and those layers together before checking your fitted sheet's stated fit range.

Do not accidentally substitute the AS5 Hybrid. A hybrid includes coils, so it does not satisfy a shopper who specifically selected no springs, even if the top comfort material is similar.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

When AS3 is the better buy

The AS3 is the middle feel in this comparison. Amerisleep describes it as medium and uses an all-foam build with its Bio-Pur and HIVE support features.

We would begin here for someone who has been happy with ordinary medium mattresses but wants to replace one that's worn out. We wouldn't automatically upgrade to AS5 because it's the more expensive-sounding model. The extra softness is useful only to someone who likes it.

If the AS3 feels too yielding in a showroom or you already prefer medium firm, move to the AS2. If it feels too hard at the shoulder when you lie on your side, then the AS5 is worth comparing. That is a better decision than simply buying the tallest mattress.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

When AS2 makes more sense

The AS2 carries a manufacturer firmness rating of 6/10, on the medium-firm side. It is still an all-foam option if you select that construction.

This is the direction we'd investigate if you sleep largely on your back or stomach, or you simply know you dislike plush beds. Those sleep positions alone don't prove you'll like a particular firmness. Your own comfort preference still matters.

One caution: AS2 is medium firm, not extra firm. If you're looking for an especially hard mattress, keep shopping for a model the manufacturer actually rates extra firm.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

The size and price trap

All three models are offered across standard sizes, including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King and California King. Amerisleep lists a 14-inch AS5 across that range, whereas AS2 and AS3 are 12 inches.

When comparing a checkout, use the same size and all-foam construction for all three. Amerisleep's category page displays promotional “starting at” prices, but those numbers are not a fair comparison of three Queen mattresses or three California Kings. A starting price may refer to a smaller size, and sale terms can change.

The true premium for the AS5 is its exact size's current cart total minus the AS3's exact size's current cart total. Verify it before claiming how much extra the softer model costs. Check state tax, optional bed base and delivery details before comparing complete totals.

All three product specifications list Twin as 38 by 74 inches, rather than the 38 by 75 inches some other brands use. A standard size name does not replace checking your frame’s actual dimensions.

On a small screen, swipe the table sideways.

Size, All FoamAS2AS3AS5
Twin$799$999$1,599
Twin XL$849$1,049$1,649
Full$999$1,199$1,799
Queen$1,049$1,249$1,849
King$1,349$1,549$2,149
California King$1,349$1,549$2,149

Exact All Foam selections checked November 2, 2026, with the displayed AS500 $500 promotion. All six sizes of each model showed in stock. The banner did not provide a dated expiration; these are snapshots, not promised future prices. Tax and optional bases are extra.

At these prices, AS3 costs $200 more than AS2 in every listed size; AS5 costs $600 more than AS3. That premium buys a different construction and softer manufacturer-rated feel, not a guarantee of better sleep.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

Check slat spacing before you celebrate finding the right feel

Amerisleep says its mattresses work on solid or suitable slatted foundations. For bases from another brand, the company specifies a maximum 2.75-inch slat gap. It also lists adjustable-base compatibility for its memory foam designs, but not traditional box springs.

That requirement can change the budget. Measure the largest gap between slats. If your current frame doesn't qualify, include a correctly supported foundation or conversion before counting the purchase as a fit.

Amerisleep advertises a 365-night mattress trial with a 30-night minimum, free coordinated return pickup, and a 20-year limited warranty: the first 10 years provide replacement for qualifying defects and the next 10 are prorated. Free shipping means curbside delivery in the contiguous U.S., not indoor setup. Foundations, adjustable bases and bedding accessories are final sale; the mattress trial does not cover them.

Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6

Our recommendation

Choose the AS3 All Foam if medium generally suits you. Choose AS5 All Foam when a soft surface is an explicit preference and you accept the taller profile and likely higher cost. Choose AS2 All Foam when you know medium firm works for you. If your old mattress is structurally sound and merely a little too firm, investigate whether a suitable topper addresses the problem before replacing the whole mattress.

Compare mattress configurations in the Sleep Product Finder. The link selects mattresses only; you choose the size, feel, construction and budget.

Sources: 1, 2, 3

Seller links

Return to the product details and seller links above ↑

Sources & research notes

Sources checked November 2, 2026 (Eastern Time). This is a manufacturer-sourced, research-based comparison. FitRestFuel has not conducted hands-on testing of these mattresses.

  1. Amerisleep AS2: All Foam configuration, size prices, specifications and support (opens in new tab)
  2. Amerisleep AS3: All Foam configuration, size prices, specifications and support (opens in new tab)
  3. Amerisleep AS5: All Foam configuration, size prices, specifications and support (opens in new tab)
  4. Amerisleep shipping: free curbside continental U.S. delivery (opens in new tab)
  5. Amerisleep 365-night trial and final-sale exclusions (opens in new tab)
  6. Amerisleep limited warranty (opens in new tab)
Back to top ↑