Blackout curtains or a sleep mask? Start with where the light gets in
You don’t need to turn your bedroom into a cave just because one streetlight is annoying. Find the light source, then choose the simplest fix you’ll actually use.
We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon prices are shown on Amazon; dated prices from other retailers are not Amazon quotes. How our links work. Prices, stock, and terms can change.
Sources last checked October 23, 2026.

Jump to a section
Look at the room before you shop
Lie down where you normally sleep and look around at the time the light bothers you. Is it a streetlight through the window, morning sun, a hallway, or a screen someone else is using? A curtain cannot block a television inside the room. A mask can help with light reaching your eyes, but only if it stays on comfortably.
For daytime sleep, check the room during the day. A curtain that looks dark at midnight may leave bright strips around the edges at noon. For an early sunrise, check the window from your pillow rather than standing in the doorway.
The NHLBI recommends a dark bedroom and specifically mentions light-blocking curtains for daytime sleep. That supports reducing unwanted light. It doesn’t establish a particular curtain or mask as the best purchase for every sleeper.
Sources: 1
What the eye-mask research says
One study in Sleep reported improvements on certain next-day learning and alertness tasks after young adults slept with an eye mask. Its abstract describes experiments with 94 and 35 participants aged 18 to 35. It wasn’t a test of branded masks or a comparison with curtains.
A published reanalysis challenged whether the results showed clear, meaningful improvements. That disagreement matters. Don’t buy a mask expecting it to improve your memory. Buy one if blocking unwanted light makes your sleep setup more comfortable.
No direct curtain-versus-mask trial is cited here. The recommendation follows their different uses, fit, and installation requirements, not a claimed research ranking.
Match the fix to the light source
On a small screen, swipe the table sideways.
| Your situation | Start with | Main thing to check |
|---|---|---|
| Travel or changing bedrooms | Sleep mask | Comfort, light seal, and packability |
| Partner wants a reading light | Sleep mask | Whether it stays comfortable on your side |
| Daytime sleep in a bright room | Blackout curtains or a combined setup | Light leaking around the installation |
| Dislike anything on your face | Curtains | Measurements and mounting hardware |
| Only one small light source | Address that source first | Whether a purchase is needed at all |
When a mask is the sensible first purchase
A mask is easy to try when you rent, travel, share a room, or want darkness without changing the windows. It also handles light coming from more than one direction. If your partner reads with a lamp, covering your own eyes may be a more workable compromise than making the whole room dark.
Fit matters. Check for light near the bridge of the nose, pressure on your eyelids, and a strap that moves or presses when you turn onto your side. A mask that feels fine sitting upright can feel very different against a pillow.
If you already dislike anything touching your face, take that preference seriously. Don’t assume a much more expensive mask will automatically solve it. Start with a design you can return under the seller’s hygiene rules, and check those rules before opening the packaging.
When curtains are the better investment
Curtains make more sense when the whole bedroom needs darkening, two people want the same result, or a mask keeps coming off. They can also be the more practical choice for regular daytime sleep if you want to move around the room without wearing anything.
The hidden issue is installation. Blackout fabric is only part of the result. Light can enter above the rod, below the hem, through the center opening, and around the sides. Buying thicker fabric doesn’t close a gap.
Measure the window, the planned mounting position, and the space around it. Check whether the advertised width refers to one panel or the whole pair. Then compare the seller’s hanging instructions with your actual window. Include the cost of rods, brackets, or a track, and confirm that your wall and mounting method can safely support the installation.
For a pair, separate panel width from usable coverage. Two 57-inch panels contain 114 inches of flat fabric in total, but folds and overlap reduce the span they cover. Do not use that total as a promise that a 114-inch window will be blacked out.
Sources: 4
Two designs worth understanding
Manta’s original sleep-mask design uses adjustable eye cups and an adjustable strap. That gives you more ways to position the seal than a flat piece of fabric. It doesn’t guarantee that the cup shape will suit your face or your side-sleeping position. Check the exact version, since the brand sells several different masks.
If you are choosing between Manta models, our Manta PRO versus Original comparison explains what the extra cost buys for side sleeping, strap position and ventilation.
IKEA’s gray MAJGULL blackout curtain listing, article 504.178.12, is a pair with heading tape in a 57-by-98-inch panel size. It’s one concrete option to compare with your measurements. The listing shows multiple hanging methods; required hanging hardware needs to be checked separately.
These are examples of a configurable mask and a full-room window treatment. They aren’t hands-on test winners. Compare the features against your problem first, then read recent owner comments about light leakage, strap fit, fabric care, and installation.
Read reviews for the problem you have
For masks, look for reviewers who mention their sleeping position and where light entered. “Super comfortable” is less helpful than a clear description of whether the cup pressed against a pillow or the strap caught in hair. Face shape is individual, so even a detailed review is a clue rather than a guarantee.
For curtains, check whether the reviewer is discussing the fabric itself or the finished installation. A bright edge may reflect how the curtain was hung. A thin-looking fabric photo might be taken with direct sun behind it. Useful reviews explain the window, daylight conditions, dimensions, and mounting method.
Keep product versions separate. A review for a room-darkening curtain isn’t automatically evidence about a blackout version with a similar name. The same goes for a mask sold in several shapes. Match the actual item number or model whenever possible.
The small ownership details matter
A mask touches your face, so read its cleaning instructions before deciding it’s convenient. Can you wash the whole thing? Do the cups detach? How long does it take to dry? Manta’s FAQ provides washing instructions for its mask, but use the instructions for the exact model you buy.
Curtains also need care, and long panels can be awkward to wash or dry. Check the fabric’s instructions and what is practical with your laundry setup. If you’ll be opening them daily, think about whether the hanging method moves smoothly instead of catching and leaving a gap.
You may not need to choose only one. Curtains can address most of the window light, with a mask reserved for travel or occasional early mornings. But buy the second item because the first left a specific problem, not because a bedroom shopping list says you need both.
Sources: 5
Test the light at the time it bothers you
Check a mask while lying in your usual position, not just sitting upright. Check curtains during the daylight or streetlight conditions that prompted the purchase. Do this while you can adjust the fit or use any applicable return option.
If a mask keeps coming off or bothers your face, focus on the window treatment. If curtains leave a small residual leak, a mask may still be useful. Buy the second item for that remaining problem.
Products in this guide
Compare the exact model, included accessories, delivery, and return terms on the seller’s page.
We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon prices are shown on Amazon; dated prices from other retailers are not Amazon quotes. How our links work. Prices, stock, and terms can change.
Manta Sleep Mask
Choose it for: A portable option with adjustable eye cups and strap
Check before ordering: Face fit and comfort against your pillow still need testing; versions differ.
View Manta Original mask on AmazonOpens AmazonIKEA MAJGULL blackout curtains, gray
Choose it for: Darkening the room when you can mount a properly sized pair
Check before ordering: The fabric cannot eliminate gaps around the installation; budget for hardware.
Check price & availabilityOpens ikea.comA few more questions
Are blackout curtains better than a sleep mask?
They solve the problem differently. Curtains darken the room; a mask blocks light at your eyes. Choose based on the light source, installation options, and what you find comfortable.
Will blackout fabric make the room completely dark?
Not necessarily. Gaps around the sides, top, bottom, or center can still let in light. Measurements and installation matter.
Sources & research notes
Sources checked October 23, 2026.
- NHLBI: dark bedrooms and light-blocking curtains for daytime sleep (opens in new tab)
- Greco et al.: eye masks, learning, and alertness, Sleep (2023) (opens in new tab)
- Manta Sleep Mask: adjustable eye-cup design (opens in new tab)
- IKEA MAJGULL: exact curtain dimensions and hanging options (opens in new tab)
- Manta: model-specific use and washing FAQ (opens in new tab)
- Reanalysis (2023): questions about eye-mask learning and alertness findings (opens in new tab)


